I’m not a blogger vs PRs.

In: Uncategorized

22 Jul 2008

Vero wrote a really good piece today about the relationship between bloggers and PRs. It was mainly in regards to technology journalism, but the points are valid across everything and the comments bring up really interesting points from both sides.

I don’t think it comes as a surprise that the PR / blogger relationship can be strained, and the fault lies on both sides.

I have friends in PR, I have friends who blog and I have friends who work in print media. All of us are battling it out for our little piece of the pie, and we all have to remember one thing about each other. It’s my motto for life, which I repeat to myself whenever things don’t work out how I planned.

They’re Just Doing Their Job.

For every PR that sends me info on a security tether after contacting me about a shoe website (this actually happened and she got very hostile when I said it wasn’t relevant) there’s one who couriers over a lipstick last minute so I can fill a gap in my video. For every PR who won’t return my phonecall when I ask for information on a product, there’s another who takes me to Nobu for dinner to talk about their new clients.

Similarly, for every PR who calls me to check what I’m working on so (s)he can send me relevant press releases or samples, there’s one who tells my colleague they won’t send anything to Catwalk Queen (even images) because they’re ‘not doing online’.

[name and shame removed because, ironically, they have now invited me to something. No idea if it was after seeing this - I doubt it - but if it was, thanks for listening!]

By nature, bloggers write opinions, they’re honest and they don’t hold back. The freedom of blogging vs print media is what appealed to me in the first place. I know we’re a bit scary because we won’t pander to people quite so easily. We’re also a bit contradictory. We want to be treated with the same respect as press, but at the same time, we don’t want to be treated like press. We want to be recognised for what we are. A new breed of writers who bring together old skills and new ideas in order to deliver content in a new way.

But those ‘weaknesses’ are also our strengths. If a product is good, blogger buzz can really sell it. Plenty of people have now realised the power of ‘underground’ buzz from new influentials (argh, jargon-speak) and witnessing the PR about turn has been really fantastic for me. All I’ve ever asked is that PRs show some kind of interest in understanding bloggers, and that definitely seems to be the case (as a whole) now. So for those who’re out there flying the flag for good PR practice, thanks. Those who aren’t…go to your clients, tell them about blogs and get them to invest some money in targeting them.

Contrary to popular belief, we’re not just in it for the freebies.

3 Responses to I’m not a blogger vs PRs.

Avatar

nuttycow

July 23rd, 2008 at 4:30 pm

Yeah you are, don’t lie ;)

I wish I got freebies for my blog! HA!

Avatar

Forever Amber

July 23rd, 2008 at 7:41 pm

It’s still amazing to me that some brands won’t deal with bloggers, especially considering the audience they could be reaching. So short-sighted of them…

But yes, it’s important to recognise that they’re just doing a job. Some of them better than others ;)

Avatar

Krsjn

July 24th, 2008 at 7:31 pm

That’s a pretty fair and balanced view. I guess that whilst bloggers and journalists are often on the receiving end of poor PR, they’re also in a privileged position to be able to publicly vent about it when they’ve had enough.

That said, I don’t think pitching to bloggers is different to pitching to anyone, inasmuch that you need to be able to recognise a good story, tailor what you’re saying to who you’re saying it to, and recognise the limitations of your story.

It would be just as bad to pitch a story about a B2B logistics company to Financial Sector Technology magazine rather than Logistics Manager, as it would to pitch the same story to ShinyShiny. And how you say it is just as important…

Problematically tho – surely the people reading Vero’s open letter on her blog aren’t the ones she should be moaning at…

Comment Form

About Me

I'm a fashion, beauty & lifestyle writer based in London. By day, I edit celeb shopping site The Nod. In my spare time, I run curvy style blog Big Girls Browse and contribute to sites like Domestic Sluttery and Dorkadore.

I also created Catwalk Queen, but please note I no longer contribute to it.

Gemma@GemmaCartwright.com
Twitter // @GemmaCartwright

  • Imee: Looks gorgeous! I love the details on the first, but the second one is fab, even if you claim it was [...]
  • Gemma: Iso, how long's it been since you saw Kat? Obvs far too long...time for a reunion I reckon. [...]
  • Kat Hannaford: Teehee, I feel so famous! I loved being a model for Gemma - anyone needing a hair stylist, she co [...]
  • Isabelle: Kat's hair is blonde?! Does look really lovely though, good work Gemma! [...]
  • links for 2010-03-25 « feeling listless: [...] Gemma Cartwright » Blog Archive » Company hearts bloggers Company hearts bloggers http://ff. [...]

Gemma’s Virtual Willpower