The great mascara hunt: Estee Lauder Sumptuous

In: Beauty| Reviews

13 Jun 2009

It’s time for another mascara review, as I hunt for the perfect lash perfector. I’m going to try and alternate between makeup counter options and bargain alternatives, because I truly believe there are some £5 mascaras out there that really do the job.

sumptuousToday, however, is the turn of the pricey ‘Sumptuous’ from Estee Lauder, a £17+ treat in a swish gold tube that promises bold volume and lift.

Now I like drama, and when I was buying this, that was what I was promised. Well, actually I was told I should try the TurboLash with its vibrating brush, but the idea of putting something that vibrates so close to my eyes freaks me out, as does the £27.40 price tag. So Sumptuous it was.

All in all, this does the job. It’s a proper old-school mascara, with a classic mid-sized bristle brush and quite a thick, dense creamy texture. Where it really impressed me was that it just doesn’t clump. Cheaper mascaras of a similar thickness (Rimmel Volume Flash, for example) give bold results but need loads of combing through to separate the lashes after application. With this, I only needed a couple of coats for a daytime lash, but I found I could keep on adding it without any clumping.

However, it takes quite a lot of coats for anything resembling the false lash look I like, but I do have high hopes when it comes to that. As a does-it-all daytime mascara, it looks the part, stays on all day, and doesn’t weigh down the lashes. Whether it’s worth £17 I’m not sure, but the lack of clumps definitely makes it a cut above many rivals.

Estee Lauder Sumptuous Mascara £17.13

Before: Maybelline Stiletto Lash
Next: Rimmel Glam’Eyes

Comment Form

About Me

I'm a fashion, beauty & lifestyle writer based in London. By day, I edit celeb shopping site The Nod. In my spare time, I run curvy style blog Big Girls Browse and contribute to sites like Domestic Sluttery and Dorkadore.

I also created Catwalk Queen, but please note I no longer contribute to it.

Gemma@GemmaCartwright.com
Twitter // @GemmaCartwright

  • Imee: Looks gorgeous! I love the details on the first, but the second one is fab, even if you claim it was [...]
  • Gemma: Iso, how long's it been since you saw Kat? Obvs far too long...time for a reunion I reckon. [...]
  • Kat Hannaford: Teehee, I feel so famous! I loved being a model for Gemma - anyone needing a hair stylist, she co [...]
  • Isabelle: Kat's hair is blonde?! Does look really lovely though, good work Gemma! [...]
  • links for 2010-03-25 « feeling listless: [...] Gemma Cartwright » Blog Archive » Company hearts bloggers Company hearts bloggers http://ff. [...]

Gemma’s Virtual Willpower